Christmas Desserts NYC Benji Buns

The Sweetest Christmas Tradition in NYC: Benji's Buns Holiday Menu Is Here

December 18, 20258 min read

Looking for festive things to do in NYC this Christmas? Forget the crowded holiday markets and overpriced hot chocolate stands—the sweetest way to celebrate the season just dropped at Benji's Buns in the West Village.

Our limited-edition Christmas menu is officially here, featuring four holiday-inspired cinnamon bun flavors that taste like the season in every gooey, frosted bite. Whether you're a local looking for unique Christmas desserts in Manhattan or a visitor searching for 'best holiday treats NYC,' this is your new must-try destination.

Introducing the Benji's Buns Christmas Menu

This isn't your average holiday dessert menu. We've taken our famous oversized, gooey cinnamon buns and infused them with the flavors, nostalgia, and magic of Christmas. Each bun is baked fresh daily at our West Village shop and available for a limited time only.

Here's what's on the menu this season:

1. Gingerbread Bun

The taste of Christmas, baked into a bun. Our Gingerbread flavor combines warm spices—cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg, and cloves—with molasses-infused dough and a sweet vanilla glaze. It's like biting into a gingerbread house, but way better (and no stale candy).

Perfect for: Anyone who loves classic holiday flavors, cozy vibes, and that nostalgic Christmas morning feeling.

2. Milk 'N' Cookies Bun

Remember leaving cookies and milk out for Santa? Now you can eat them in one gloriously indulgent bun. We've loaded this creation with crushed cookies, a creamy milk glaze, and extra cookie crumbles on top. It's childhood nostalgia meets adult-sized portions.

Perfect for: Cookie lovers, kids at heart, and anyone who thinks Santa had the right idea about late-night snacks.

3. Peppermint Mocha Bun

Your favorite holiday coffee drink, reimagined as a cinnamon bun. Rich chocolate dough swirled with peppermint, topped with mocha frosting and crushed candy cane. It's festive, it's decadent, and it's exactly what your December needs.

Perfect for: Coffee addicts, peppermint fans, and anyone who wants their dessert to feel like a holiday celebration.

4. The Grinch - Mean Matcha! (Weekends Only)

Our most playful creation yet. This bright green matcha-infused bun is topped with white chocolate cream cheese frosting and looks as festive as it tastes. It's a little sassy, a little sweet, and totally Instagram-worthy. Fair warning: this one's only available on weekends, so plan accordingly.

Perfect for: Matcha lovers, Grinch fans, weekend warriors, and anyone who wants a bun that's as fun as it is delicious.

Plus: Our Classic Holiday Favorites

Don't worry—our beloved staple flavors are still available alongside the Christmas specials:

Original Glazed: The classic that started it all

Vanilla Frosted: Rich cream cheese frosting perfection

Lotus Biscoff: The fan favorite that never disappoints

Whether you're a traditionalist or an adventurous flavor chaser, there's something for everyone this holiday season.

Why Benji's Buns Is the Perfect Christmas Activity in NYC

If you're searching for 'fun things to do in NYC for Christmas,' 'unique holiday experiences Manhattan,' or 'best Christmas desserts West Village,' here's why Benji's Buns should be at the top of your list:

It's a True New York Experience

Located in the heart of the West Village at 122 Christopher Street, Benji's Buns captures everything magical about Christmas in NYC. Twinkling lights, cozy vibes, the smell of fresh-baked cinnamon wafting through the air—it's the kind of place that makes you feel like you're in a holiday movie.

Perfect for All Ages

Whether you're visiting with kids, your partner, friends, or solo, everyone loves cinnamon buns. It's one of those rare activities that genuinely appeals to the whole family. Plus, our buns are shareable (one bun feeds 1-2 people), making them perfect for group outings.

Open Late for Holiday Crowds

Unlike most bakeries that close early, we're open until midnight on weekends. That means you can stop by after ice skating at Rockefeller Center, after a Broadway show, or after exploring the holiday lights in the West Village. Late-night Christmas dessert runs just got a whole lot better.

Instagram-Worthy Moments

Let's be real: if you didn't post it, did it even happen? Our Christmas buns—especially The Grinch—are designed to be photographed. The festive colors, the gooey toppings, the holiday presentation. Your Instagram feed (and your followers) will thank you.

Support a Local Small Business

When you visit Benji's Buns, you're supporting a young entrepreneur who started his bakery journey in London and brought his dream to NYC. Every bun is made with care, passion, and a commitment to quality. Shopping local during the holidays? This counts.

How to Make Benji's Buns Part of Your NYC Christmas Plans

Here are some ways to incorporate Benji's Buns into your holiday itinerary:

Christmas Morning Tradition

Start Christmas Day with a box of fresh-baked holiday buns. Order online for pickup on Christmas morning (check our hours) and make it a new family tradition. Pair with coffee, hot chocolate, or champagne for the ultimate festive breakfast.

Post-Shopping Treat

Spent the day navigating holiday shopping crowds in SoHo or the Village? Reward yourself with a Peppermint Mocha bun and a latte. You've earned it.

Date Night Dessert Stop

Planning a romantic evening in the West Village? End the night at Benji's Buns for a cozy, sweet finish. Our late hours mean you can stop by even after dinner and a walk through the twinkling holiday streets.

Holiday Party Catering

Hosting a Christmas party, office gathering, or holiday brunch? Our Christmas menu is available for catering. Imagine a platter of Gingerbread, Milk 'N' Cookies, and Peppermint Mocha buns as your dessert spread. Guests will be talking about it all year.

Tourist Must-Do

Visiting NYC for the holidays? Add Benji's Buns to your itinerary alongside the tree at Rockefeller Center, the holiday windows on Fifth Avenue, and the Christmas markets. It's a quintessential New York experience that locals actually love too.

Other Festive Things to Do Near Benji's Buns

While you're in the West Village grabbing your holiday buns, here are other nearby Christmas activities to round out your day:

Stroll through Washington Square Park: The arch looks magical decorated for the holidays.

Explore Christopher Street Shops: Browse unique boutiques and local shops for one-of-a-kind gifts.

Check Out Holiday Lights: The West Village is known for its charming, festive decorations on historic brownstones.

Visit Nearby Coffee Shops: Grab a specialty drink at one of the Village's cozy cafes.

Walk the High Line: See the park transformed with winter installations and holiday lights (short subway or walk away).

The West Village is one of NYC's most festive neighborhoods during the holidays—and Benji's Buns is right in the heart of it all.

Limited Time Only: Don't Miss Out

Here's the thing about holiday specials: they don't last forever. Our Christmas menu is available for a limited time only, and once the season ends, these flavors disappear until next year.

And let's be honest—The Grinch bun is only here on weekends. If you want to try the most Instagrammable, matcha-powered, green machine of a bun, you need to plan accordingly.

Don't be the person scrolling through Instagram in January, seeing everyone's Gingerbread and Peppermint Mocha posts, wishing you'd made the trip. Come now. Taste the magic. Make it part of your Christmas tradition.

Order Online or Visit In-Store

Ready to try the sweetest holiday experience in NYC? Here's how to get your hands on these limited-edition Christmas buns:

Order Online for Pickup or Delivery

Head to www.benjisbuns.com to browse the full Christmas menu, place your order, and schedule pickup or delivery. You can order single buns or grab a variety pack to try multiple flavors.

Visit Us in the West Village

Stop by our shop at 122 Christopher Street to see the holiday menu in person, smell the fresh-baked magic, and grab your buns hot out of the oven.

Hours:

Weekdays: 10 AM – 10 PM

Friday – Sunday: 10 AM – Midnight

Pro tip: Come early on weekends if you want to try The Grinch bun—it's a fan favorite and tends to sell out.

Join the Bun Club for Holiday Perks

Bun Club members earn points on every purchase (including Christmas buns!), get early access to flavor drops, and unlock exclusive holiday perks. Sign up at www.benjisbuns.com/bunclub and start earning rewards today.

Why This Christmas Menu Matters

At Benji's Buns, we're not just selling cinnamon rolls—we're creating moments. Moments of joy, nostalgia, connection, and pure indulgence. Christmas is about traditions, memories, and sharing something special with the people you love.

Our Christmas menu is designed to be part of that. Whether it's a Gingerbread bun on Christmas morning, a Peppermint Mocha treat after shopping, or a box of holiday buns for your office party, we want to make your season a little sweeter.

Because if there's one thing the holidays need, it's more gooey, oversized, impossibly delicious cinnamon buns.

Make It a Christmas to Remember

This holiday season, skip the generic desserts and crowded chain bakeries. Come to Benji's Buns in the West Village and experience Christmas flavors that are as unique, creative, and unforgettable as New York City itself.

Whether you're a local or a visitor, whether you're looking for fun things to do in NYC for Christmas or just craving something ridiculously delicious, our holiday menu is waiting for you.

Gingerbread. Milk 'N' Cookies. Peppermint Mocha. The Grinch. Limited time. Unlimited joy.

The sweetest Christmas tradition in NYC is waiting for you.

Order your Christmas buns now at www.benjisbuns.com

---

Keywords: Christmas things to do NYC, festive activities New York City, best Christmas desserts Manhattan, holiday treats West Village, Christmas cinnamon buns NYC, unique holiday experiences NYC, festive bakery New York, Christmas menu Benji's Buns, holiday flavors West Village, fun Christmas activities Manhattan, where to get Christmas desserts NYC, seasonal buns New York City, gingerbread cinnamon rolls NYC, peppermint mocha dessert Manhattan, best holiday bakery West Village

Back to Blog